she seemed so into the cake at the beginning.

but she didnt even do anything, talk about expendable

So true quite a shock

She was drooling and stuff so I just thought SHE would be the culprit!

I figured pinkie slept-ate the cake.

agree

She seemed really interested.

Applejack looked guilty but apparently she didn't take one bite of the Marzipan Mascarpone Meringue Madness.

I really thought others would think it was Twilight Sparkle. Though I do tend to overanalyze things. I thought since she was helping Pinkie solve the case it would make her immediately seem innocent but really it was her. The only thing I really noticed was that I saw the curtains go down; they could only do that with magic.

I thought it was gonna be either Pinkie or Dash. Because Pinkie could have ate it in her sleep then proceed to blame everyone else and the lesson would come out of that.

and quite frankly I just wouldn't put sneaking cake behind Dashie. She seems so devious sometimes.

I thought it was Rainbow Dash because of the speed when she whipped out of there.

Yeah true

She could've eaten it in her sleep. XD

Good point that Twilight could have been pretending to help solve the case to cover up her own guilt.

Ahhh I was also thinking that too

i thought she was dreaming about the cake.