That's a tough one, actually. I've never really figured out who I like her best with (though I'm starting to see the appeal with FlutterPie and FlutterCord - judging by how you've written them I guess you like those pairings too!).

I mostly imagine Fluttershy to be extremely awkward and crushing on someone, but being too shy to fess up and admit her feelings, causing her to do silly and embarrassing things whenever her crush approaches her!

That's how I imagine things to be with her. I just haven't figured out who I like her best with!

This makes sense. They're both nice, don't talk much, and shy-although Big Macintosh seems to be a rather silent pony and doesn't talk much.

Glelsey, ur awesome. I do like PinkieShy and FlutterCord! Both so cute!

Oh, and Flarity rocks too! I like those 3!