Wait why is this being done in rounds how does that make it a fair pick?

love this! i think it sould be only buffy and not spuffy or bangel couse that will just break out fights between the fanbases!

I agree with x-missmckena-x, rounds doesn't seem like the best way to decide this. Feels like one pick would be better, especially since I think one of these picks has slightly better icons than the other, so a less liked icon might make it through to a next round just because it was on a pick with less strong competition. That's not to say I think any of the icons submitted are less than great, they are all very good, I just think either a normal pick or maybe a countdown where people vote off least favourites would work better.

There will be one pick for each icon.By rounds I mean first or second pick.The winners of each pick will be challenged so that we have the new spot icon...

I get thats whats going to happen but that still doesnt make it a fair choosing system!

I agree I don't think rounds are the right way to do this. Since a few people feel that way wouldn't it be better to do one pick or a countdown as suggested? No point picking a spot icon if the spot users aren't happy with the selection process.

This one!!!

I like this one. Very pretty. But rounds? It's not an even match.