After the picture, i would not miss the oppurtunity to kiss him ;)

Well now my answer is highly subjective as to which VERSION of Phantom is standing there.

Gerik- Rude gesture, call him a basement dweller, and tell him that no, really the sunburn isn't that bad PLEASE GO GET A LIFE! (and some voice lessons)
ALW stage- *drrrooooolll* Angel of Music? Uhh, right. Whatever. I'll play along. I get to grope him, right?
Kay Version- Is he high/pissed off? Yes, hand at the level of my eyes, walk the hell away VERY fast. No, seems lucid to me, engage in conversation and go hang out. If I'm very lucky I can seduce him! *squee*
Lon Chaney- Smmmmmoooooch! Tell him he's a cutie pie and watch him become highly confused and maybe a little weirded out.
Charles Dance version- Let's go for a picnic. ;)
Robert Englund version- Is he angry? Oh, sod it! I don't care if he is, c'mere baby! (And stop picking at that or it will never heal!!!)
Claude Rains version- Invite him in for drinks and noms. Then just sit there and drool while he talks. Mmm I love Claude's speaking voice.
Dario Argento version- Go for one of my swords.
Leroux Erik- Don't care if he's angry. Don't care if he's psychotic. Take me, I'm yours! Wait, where are you going?!

There's a bunch more versions, but I figured these would be the most recognizable.

Haha yes Phantomess you are allowed 2 grope the ALW stage phantom, i would aswell if the phantom behined the mirror looked like the Ramin Karimloo phantom ;)

That would be my answer only for Leroux. I'm with Phantomess on that there should be different reactions for each phantom.

Gerik- Pause for a few seconds... Then b***h slap him after taking his mask off... On the sunburn side. Hopefully it stung.
ALW stage- Hopefully its TMG Phantom. If it is... *drool* If its Michael Crawford... Meh, your cool and all, I just don't really like you... What? I don't!
Kay Version- Hopefully he's high... because (AS A JOKE), I'd ask him about that jar... And hopefully if he didn't kill me I'd ask him to tell me a bunch of stories about what happened between Giovanni and Nadir's stories, since we never got to read about that...
Lon Chaney- Give him an actual hand grenade to use at the end of his movie so that he dies the way he's supposed to... Rather than having an EMPTY HAND OF DOOM!!!
Charles Dance version- Ask him to sing Faust for me...
Robert Englund version- Sing his Don Juan Triumphant because its JUST SO PRETTY!!! And take him to a plastic surgeon to get a face stitched on permanently so it doesn't melt.
Claude Rains version- Ask him to play his concerto... So I don't anger him. And talk about his daughter-- What? They cut that out? So its incest now? WTF???
Dario Argento version- Go take him to the doctor to get a rabis shot... And maybe a new set of friends... And a haircut.
Leroux Erik- My answer to the question. Because he's just frickin' amazing, and everything in between.

TOTALlY!!! :D

I think this would be my choice even if I was a girl.
As much as I'd like to see his lair, it'd still be this.

Following Phantomess' example...

Gerik: BWAHAHAHAHAHA.
ALW Stage: Totallyyyyyy.
Kay: Depends if he's high or not. If he's high, I'm gonna play matchmaker. If he wasn't high... >D
Chaney: *huggle*
Dance: I would SO HIT THAT. With picnics and opera singing! :D
Englund: He scares me. I don't think I'd do much. (I has not seen that version.)
Claude Rains: re:Dance, minus picnics. He can play his music instead. pretty, pretty music... *is in love with the LotB*
Argento: Ew. Just EW.
Animated: My heart belongs to another animated guy. Sorry.
Leroux: SEX!

hehehe! that waz funny phantomess! if it was the ALW stage guy i'd let him take me anywhere and i mean ANYWHERE!:) i waz stuck between take his mask off and kiss him and let him take me down to his lair, but i picked the lair cuz then we would have alone time... :)

it's hard to say what I'll do (If it was Gerik)
I'll stare at him trance-like and follow him to his lair then kiss him and never let go or just be too shock to move:)

Again, it depends on which one it is. But if it was one that I like (there are many... *peverted laugh*), I'd probably let him lead me to his lair... then, LET THE GAMES BEGIN! *wink*... after that, I'd have some singing lessons... then I'd go back and jump Raoul, to see if he's as good as Erik.

And now you now a little more about who I am.

This one and the camera one lol.

Yes it's subjective to the version but I think regardless if anyone was watching me from behind a mirror I'd have to ask him some things, mostly pertaining to WHY he was behind my mirror. I'm super paranoid so I'd probably grumble about him scaring the mc boogers out of me any then jump him, grab onto his arm and never let go.

i will go with him

How about a NORMAL father-daughter relationship?

At the time when Christine came in to contact with the Phantom Raoul wasn't her lover just a friend, it had been so long so how could they have fallen in love at the snap of your fingers?

I would do both:
1. I would walk to him and let him lead me into his lair
2. I would pull him through the mirror, take his mask off and kiss the loving daylights outta him