I liked Peter Pan as a villain but i can't imagine a comeback storyline for him. His story ended in the best way when Rumple killed him.

So my choice is Cora! I like good Regina but i don't want her to be completely good. Cora can create some drama....

Yep ,they other 4 are the only characters that I trully hate from the show :p .
I would like for Zelena to come back ,there's so much to be said on her character and her relationship with Regina ,plus i don't know but they way Rumple "killed" her ,maybe she could come back.

Love Cora, Pan and Zelena.
Like Tamara.
Hate Greg.
Pan is my favorite villain but I love Cora the most as a character.

She didn't get the send off Cora did or even Pan. No one cried for her. No one even cared. Cora's death was tragic and beautiful. Pan was a great villain but he was pure evil and his defeat had all the satisfaction of vanquishing a dragon. Zelena's just didn't feel right. It was so unfair. She deserved better.

I nearly picked Zelena but my doubts that she's dead stopped me. I think she's still alive, mainly because of that green smoke that formed after she "died".

I hope your right, but I'm afraid that might just have been her magic. Sort of like her dying curse.

It did happen when Dorothy thought she was dead, so it could be that she was forming herself back to life again. A popular theory is that she is disguised as Marian.

Ugh. I really hope thats not true. That would be awful. I really like Marian. I don't want her to be a fake.

Or Cora.

@minervadawn, completely agree on the Zelena thing.
I love Cora and I miss her a lot but her death scene was so beautiful I don't wanna mess with it.

I'm still not sure Zelena is really dead.

Although I love Cora more as a villain but Zelena had so much potential and her story is not finished, she has to return

But I want Cora back too tho !

I loved Peter Pan's games.