Milah is an ungrateful and unfaithful little whore!

Henry's cute.

Milah is terrible.

Milah is the WORST character on the show.

BY FAR!!

Listen to yourselves! You are beating down this woman and saying things that are horrible and completely untrue.

Milah? A whore? Whore: a woman who engages in sexual acts for money. Last time I checked, the writers gave no indication that she sold her body for money. Do I agree with the fact that she abandoned Bae? No. Could there have been an alternative way of leaving Rumple? Yes. But I don't blame her for wanting to escape the marriage.

Ungrateful? For what? A husband that viewed her as a mother, almost as a piece of property and not as a woman that he loved? Being the wife of people they called a coward? Read TDDD's article and you'll see what kind of lifestyle she was probably forced to live being the wife of a coward.

The worst character on the show? Absolutely not. Rumple killed countless people. Including the woman he was supposed to love and then lied to his son about it. He never did anything for anyone else unless it he got something out of it too. And Cora! She killed her own daughter's love, ripping his heart out and crushing it. Right in front of her! She's killed countless people too! But Milah is the worst character on the show?

If any of you are Rumple and Belle shippers, I would have thought you'd be glad Milah left Rumple. After all, if she hadn't, he would have never met Belle. In fact, for SwanFire shippers, Bae would have probably never met Emma. So I would have thought you'd be a little more thankful for Milah. The writers would probably be disgusted by the things you've been saying about her. Sure, you don't like her for what she did, but all of the hate is completely unnecessary.

I always try to defend Milah the best I can. I am thankful to her and Rumple, since Swanfire is what I ship. I think King George and Greg are worse than Cora and Rumple though TBH, but not Milah. After 2x14 it was Rumple's fault she left him, she told him not to go to the ogre wars and he still went. If Milah didn't think he was a coward before that then why go? Your loved ones are the ones you should care about what they think of you, not random villagers. ^

matchesrulezu we say what we say because it's true

^ Delusion at its finest.

Yes you are

This is hard. To be honest both annoy the sh*t out of me haha. Picking Henry cuz I can't really compare him to other characters cuz he's a kid and maybe as an adult he'll get better.
@matchesrulezu, I don't think the writers would be disgusted cuz I feel like Milah was just created as a plot device, a reason for Hook to hate Rumpel. She wasn't developed. They never give her any backstory so everone can just guess. If from the little you saw of her you liked her, you guess something positive. If you didn't like her, you guess something negative. My opinion on Milah: I totally respet her for leaving her husband if she stopped loving him (she has a right for happiness like everyone) but abandoning her child like that was what made me dislike her. Also, the way she treated Rumpel when she told him she would prefer him to be dead than to be known as a coward. The worst part about that was it came out to me as if she had really, really meant it, not just said it cuz she was mad at that moment. Before he was gone to war she loved him and didn't care about what people thought. When he was a coward it looked like social convictions were the most important thing to her. To me all this makes her: a bad mother, a bad person (but definitely NOT the worse, being some villains I love worse), and a character I didn't enjoy or think was really good and thought out properly.

If she wasn't in love with Rumple anymore fine. But did she have to always treat him terrible, always insult, and constantly say she wished he died on the battle field? This just makes her despicable! She could have told Rumple that she wasn't in love with him anymore before she left instead of making him think something terrible happened to her like being "kidnapped" by Hook. Plus the most unforgiving thing of all, she left her son! Rumple had to tell their five year old son that his mother was never coming back, that she was dead. She was the coward, not Rumple!

I did admit that she could have chosen an alternative, better way of leaving Rumple. And I did say that I didn't agree with her abandoning Bae. But Rumple would have had to be really dense to not see that Milah no longer loved him. She avoided him whenever she could and was mean to him when she was around him. I think Rumple got the hint, but just never acknowledged it because of Bae.

Was she cruel in her own way? Yeah, she was. I just don't feel like this makes her a whore, ungrateful, or the worst character on the show. That's just what I was trying to say. It just seemed like people were being really extreme in their hatred of her.

I don't hate or like her, but I just look at it from the point of view as if she were a person.. I can understand her motive, but don't agree with the way she handled things. That doesn't mean you have to hate her. It's a waste of energy for a plot device. Especially this late in the show. I wish they had given her more of a backstory so we could see and better understand the kind of person she was. It may have helped us get a better understanding of why things happened the way they did.

^Yeah, I agree with the last bit. If she hadn't just been treated as a plot device probably a lot less people would hate her. That was a kinda unfair thing to do to a character.

Yes I agree there are far more horrible characters on the show *King George, Greg* and how does leaving her family make her a whore. @Matchesrulezu gave a definition and that was NOT Milah in any way whatsoever.

Worst mother ever....how can I ever like this woman?

Evilregal14 because she was leaving her family for another man and having an affair

You clearly haven't read the definition then...

Milah is a far more interesting character .

Hate her

He's such a sweet boy.:') <3 Never cared for Milah that much...