I have no idea! They are both so gorgeous!

Rose is very beautiful actress. Specially in Charmed.
Just in this photo, she looks weird --------------->

Rose was really pretty when she was younger, in Charmed for instance. But now.. all the plastic surgery kinda ruined her :( It's sad, I enjoyed her in Charmed a lot.

^ yeah! I know! what a shame :(

Rose had a car accident, and left her a cut on her face, so she had no choice, she had to fix her face with plastic surgery.

I'm terribly sorry for her, that's a horrible thing... the poor girl...

but that still does not explain why she had her lips done. Or why she had her eyebrows done. All those were not needed to fix a scar. Not that I'm against beauty-plastic surgery.. Just that she really overdone it.

bottom line is.. personal drama aside, you can't possibly deny Emilie is more beautiful.

Yes you can. If you think Rose is prettier you can defiantly deny it. I'm sorry but not everyone has to think Rose is pretty. Why do you care that people think Rose is prettier? It's not like they've said she's ugly or anything.

But I'm not gonna argue this topic anymore because I really don't care, they are both pretty in their own ways end of story.

^^I can see your point. Poor girl.. :(

All the way!