Bill Shatner or Chris Pine? Who's the real Capt.Kirk? Poll Results - James T. Kirk

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

James T. Kirk Bill Shatner or Chris Pine? Who's the real Capt.Kirk?

75 fans picked:

Bill Shatner for sure!

77%

Love both

12%

Chris Pine!

11%

makintosh posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

22 comments

	spikesgal picked Love both: well i love chris pine cause and makes a funny captain kirk in the star trek film but william shatner is the orginal and he's amazing so really i like them both! posted over a year ago.

	StarbucksBunny picked Chris Pine!: hate shatner. pine is way better! posted over a year ago.

	FaithLehane picked Bill Shatner for sure!: Sorry to say Pine didn't impress me much. The Shat! posted over a year ago.

	SHADOW-FAN3854 picked Bill Shatner for sure!: go shatner! posted over a year ago.

	McCoyLover picked Bill Shatner for sure!: Shatner all the way YO! he was the first, funniest, most mocked and well all around friken awsome! posted over a year ago.

	peterslover picked Bill Shatner for sure!: Shatner is #1. But Pine did a pretty good job at setting the stage for Shatner to come along. But Bill didn't have Pine when he started. Bill MADE Kirk for who he is. Do you know what I'm saying? posted over a year ago.

	makintosh picked Bill Shatner for sure!: I agree with clarklover but for me Chris Pine was only ok as captain Kirk. William Shatner can not be easily replaced, do you know what I mean? posted over a year ago.

	dorothyLN picked Bill Shatner for sure!: you hate shatner? εισαι π...... τοτε! god! i love him!!! posted over a year ago.

	Irene01 picked Bill Shatner for sure!: if you hate that legend why are you in here???! eleos! posted over a year ago.

	Feena-c picked Bill Shatner for sure!: I like Pine in the new movie, but nobody can ever come close to the Shatnerness of Shatner. Yes I can make his name into an adjective. posted over a year ago.

	spockrocks picked Chris Pine!: I love Pine. He is so hot. posted over a year ago.

	AcidBanter picked Bill Shatner for sure!: Shatner Is Kirk. But Pine did a pretty good job in the new movie. No one can beat Shatner as Kirk. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	TaladarkieJJ picked Bill Shatner for sure!: Bill? You mean William. Yes definitely Shatner as Kirk. :) posted over a year ago.

	piperlovegood picked Bill Shatner for sure!: Bill is a nickname for William, kinda like Mandy/Amanda, but no one could replace Shatner as the Legendary Captain Kirk posted over a year ago.

	Shantoo picked Bill Shatner for sure!: If you know the Shat Man there is just no competition. But I can see, for the kids, who aren't down with the OST and the classic charter that Bill has always played it would be a clear Pine pick after all he is young and 'hot' but lets face it he hasn't had time to grow into the very big boots of Capt. Kirk. He's done a good job so far though. posted over a year ago.

	ryans_love picked Love both: he's gorgeous! posted over a year ago.

	frankthe2nd picked Love both: Shatner will always be Kirk. But I really loved Pine. He did a much better job than anyone thought he would do. Hell, even Leonard Nimoy approves of him. posted over a year ago.

	TheDevilsDuches picked Bill Shatner for sure!: But Pine did a very good job! posted over a year ago.

	Cherylsh19 picked Bill Shatner for sure!: I haven't watched the movie yet, but Shatner is "the guy". No one can be better than him. posted over a year ago.

	ClassicTV picked Bill Shatner for sure!: Chris is just...no. posted over a year ago.

	Flummy picked Bill Shatner for sure!: I don't hate Chris Pine, but William Shatner is the real James Tiberius Kirk. posted over a year ago.

	Simmeh picked Bill Shatner for sure!: Chris was alright in the movies and I thought he was very handsome as a child, but William Shatner is clearly the best! And actually, I find him a lot more handsome and sexier than Pine. The way he talks and smiles... it's so captivating! posted over a year ago.

Add Your Comment

James T. Kirk

James T. Kirk Bill Shatner or Chris Pine? Who's the real Capt.Kirk?

22 comments

Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment

James T. Kirk more polls