I hate Donna.She is so whiny.(I am not whining I am ranting btw).She is also not tactfull at all she talkes about rose and his home as if it is not a sensitive topic.She travels the world and allshe can do is notice the bad things bout whats happening.The best episode of that season was midnight when she was not there
I hate Rose Tyler. The one I hate about Tennant's run is that it was plagued by her. Like in 'The Shakespeare Code' the Doctor said "Rose would know what to do"...erm Martha is way smarter the Rose and that's the writer talking not the Doctor. I seriously doubt that any of the others Doctor would have said that, especially six. Rose is an annoying companion in my (and many other people's) opinion. This is not a bashing of Billie Piper, I think she's a great actress, I just hate Rose. I even prefer Mickey to her, she's not worse than Adric but I hate her.
posted over a year ago
i thought i knew you.*holds breath*nojudgementnojudgementnojudgement
I really dislike Amy. Sometimes she was okay, but other times she just got on my nerves. I mean, kissing another man on the night before her wedding?! That's just horrible. I also found her older self really annoying, Gah.
I just couldn't feel any emotion towards her like the other companions. When the doctor left her, i actually was really happy. I felt like her character was over the top and I cant stand Catherine Tate. Her voice is the most annoying voice ever. Her acting is terrible, to me. Shes just annoying and boring as hell to me. No hate towards anyone who loves her. I respect everyone's opinion.
P.S Just felt like leaving a picture of Captain Jack ;)
Many would say it's too early to say (and they might be right) but I really dont like Clara. She has NO flaws! She is so perfect she dosen't seem human. I can't connect to or empathize with her in any way.
I know Moffat says that Clara is suppose to be "as smart if not smarter then the doctor" and that may be true but that is exactly why I hate her. Here's how I see it...
The Doctor is like Sherlock he's brillent and interesting but the way he thinks and sees the world is so unlike how we see it that it is impossible to connect to him on a personal level.
The companions are like Watson. We see the Doctor through them. They are our avatar in his world. They feel what we would feel, do what we would do, because like us they are so very very human. This is why every popular scifi show has a human element otherwise it become unrelatable. Clara is more doctorish then the doctor is, more mysterious and aloof and "alien". Imagine Sherlock with two Sherlocks. Boring right? He need a Watson to counterbalance him.
There has yet to be on episode where Clara does something that makes me go "that is so very very human". Flawed, idealistic and impulsive. Every companion must have that "human moment" :
Rose - Melancholy in End of the World when she releases everyone she knows is dead.
Martha - Indignation in Gridlock when she realized she was the rebound girl.
Donna - Awkward sexual misunderstanding "you want to MATE!!"
Amy - Recognized the connection between the sky whale and the Doctor in The Beast Below.
Rory - Jealousy (but adorable jealousy) the moment you meet him in the Eleventh Hour. **
On average it takes two episodes for me to connect with a companion Clara has had 7 and still nothing. She still has time to turn me around but as of now I'm not loving her. She's just a robot programed to be brave, smart and funny with no flaws or personality.
** notice I left out River because she never really had a "human moment" either. She is an exciting and fun minor character but she would make a terrible companion. The closest she got was her fear of endings (of losing the Doctor) something she shares with Doctor and not all that uniquely human.
This is just my impression of Clara so far. If you feel like I've misjudged her or missed something please point it out. I hate being unable to connect to the characters on doctor who and i feel like I'm floundering.
I find Rose Tyler incredibly annoying really (no offense to Billie Piper, she's a great actress, I am just talking about this specific character). I think she was just very selfish and annoying, she left her boyfriend and mother behind and when she came back and Mickey told her that he was dating someone, she was mad! I mean I hate the fact that Rose left him and Mickey just stayed there waiting for her. Also,I hate how Rose took the lead in Satan's Pit when the Doctor was gone. I mean come on. There was a soldier, an archaeologist and a boy who knew how to fix the problem with the Oods, what did Rose know? Nothing. I don't know I just felt that the show was more about her than the Doctor and I also hated her romance with both of the Doctor's regenerations.
I also hate Clara Oswin. She is impossibly to care. She is a Mary-Sue, Steven Moffat has totally screwed up Doctor Who >.<
This answer isn't about a companion although I have no problems with Rose Tyler, I don't really care for her as much as the other companions, but I will not rant about her, I will rant about Rose's mother. Although her husband died, Rose's mom is so annoying. In the first episode, she wanted the news to interview her daughter when her daughter needed some space, and she always whined about her life and Rose's.
I'm sure no judgements will be made if I say Captain Jack...right?
I just don't really find him that interesting of a character. He's better in Who than he is in Torchwood, and perhaps I'm a leetle bit biased because of that, but I dislike him. I've never been able to explain why.
Please don't judge me!
