answer this question

Doctor Who Question

If the doctor never existed, River would never have been born, and her journal wouldn't end up at the wedding. It looked like River gave it to Amy, how?

I know this is old (season 5), but it's been bugging me
 ttammie posted over a year ago
next question »

Doctor Who Answers

simpleplan said:
Rivers future self could have gave it to Amy.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Aqua_Rose said:
I can't really remember that far back, but maybe it wasn't her actual diary- maybe just a book that looked the same but not written in?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
bunnyhavoc said:
when you fall into cracks you were never born, but all the things you did are still there, the doctor was trapped on the other side and he gave the diary to river, it was blank because she had no memory of him or it got erased
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
j1edwardcullen7 said:
You have to consider the amount of times River has travelled throughout her parents' and the doctor's time streams. If you really think about how much she bounces around the time vortex, it's quite possible, indeed, that a future version of herself gave it to Amy.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
The10thDoctorDT said:
When someone starts asking questions about Doctor Who time line, that when it's gets all complicated.

Well, as I know, it's just complicated. As the 10th Doctor said it's all "Wibly Wybly, Timy Wimy Stuff"(Forgive me I don't know how to write it but i think you understand).
But I have one other explaination, it's River from the future, who was born in a time Amy can't reminber, who came at the wedding which is in her past, being told by the future version of the doctor(the one at the wedding) that this was happening or will happen or is happening. It's complicated.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »