phoeeb and piper give up way to many times it is between prue and paige but paige had her whitelighter instict as well!

i agree with u, its definetly out of prue and paige

who the hell picked piper, she only cares about leo

lol 'xxshannen1xx' I could not stop laughing :D the thing about piper! I live Piper but yes, she doesn't seem to care as much as Prue or Paige or even early Phoebe. Hell, she didn't even want to be a witch.

No Way Its Phoebe And Paige Cause Prue Didnt Even Want Her Powers Phoebe And Paige Wanted There Powers And Want To Help Save And Protect The Innocents

that has nothing to do with saving innocents

Okay,maybe Piper didn't care about saving innocents.But what if the Elders told you 'No,you can't be with the one you love,sorry.Oh,by the way,you have an innocent to save.Ciao!' I mean, they expected them to put their lives on hold and to save the world with all the stupid elderly rules.I just think that Piper couldn't deal with that as good as her sisters could.This is just my opinion.

Erm... do you all remember 'Astral Monkey' ?
She cried because of Dr. Williamson was dead, after killing like 3 people... so even though at first she was more intrested in Leo, I think that she really was one that tried to save them.

And for me it is a tie between Phoebe and Piper, just they gone a little selfish with the years, because of their love lifes and all but they are the ones who stayed on the show longer, helping innocents no matter what happened.

And the episode I remember of Phoebe, is when she was a Lounge Psychic in a hotel and she saw that the man was going to die. She really tried everything there to help him.

Sorry for the rant ^^

i think phoebe because she sees each ones death and the others dont understand how important to her that she saves them, the others dont see them die

Phoebe from 1 - 4 Season
and Paige 4 - 8 Season