Charmed

Charmed Would you rather

dermer4ever posted on Mar 20, 2010 at 11:46PM
the way this works is you list two scenarios and the next posters say which they would rather see and what not and so on.

Would you rather Prue not die and their be no Paige or the way it was

Charmed 83 replies

Click here to write a response...
Previous

Showing Replies 1-50 of 83

over a year ago mimialliwell said…
the way it was

would you rather phoebe keep her baby in season 4 and make it good or the way it was
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
keep her baby :)

would you rather christie became good or the way it was?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
she should have become good then the show could have continued

would you rather Piper and Leo with Phoebe and Cole or Phoebe and Leo and Piper and Cole
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
the way it was!

would you rather Piper to stay at Quake or have her night club P3?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
she has to have the night club everything interesting happens there

would you rather Paige stay a social worker or run magic school?
over a year ago HollyMarie said…
wink
she wasn't a social worker,she was just an assistant,so I'd say run Magic School
over a year ago RenesmeeFan said…
kiss
run magic school
would you rather snog leo or cole? (i'd pick cole ;) )
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
thats not fair can i say both!!!!

if i have to choose is day leo (my angel)

would you rather leo become and elder or stay a white lighter

over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
smile
become an elder,or else Chris wouldn't be around ;)

would you rather phoebe and cole stay together or the way it was
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
i wanna say stay together cause they were soo cute but i have o pick the way it was otherwise we would have lost some really good eps

would you rather piper have wyatt first or melinda first (like in season 2 "morality bites")
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
the way it was,so wyatt first

would you rather chris have excalibur or the way it was?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
heart
chris should've had it

would you rather marry leo or cole (i'd pick leo he's my angel)
over a year ago mellyhalliwell said…
Leo :)
I agree with u, he's an angel <33

Would you rather be the daughter of Penny or Patty?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
patty she was sooo sweet and i think i'd prefer penny as a grams

would you rather victor was in it more and closer to the girls or the way it was
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
a bit more,he was funny

would you rather richard and paige stayed together or the way it was?
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
heart
The way it was, definitely.

Would you rather Chris be the more powerful child (compared to Wyatt) or the way it was?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
the way it was i love my Wyatt although he should have had a bit more power than he did

would you rather see more of Phoebe and Paige with their kids or just have the little bit in the last ep
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
big smile
I would have preferred to see more of Paige and Phoebe as moms.

Would you rather have Charmed run for another season or end the way it did? -
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
smile
though one.I can never get enough of Charmed,but season 8 was already a unexciting extract of the previous seasons.I would say run for another season,but like a Charmed next generation.

would you rather Phoebe to keep her levitating power or the way it was?
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
heart
Keep her levitating power

Would you rather Chris have lived *woohoo!* or that he remained as "dead" in season 6? *sob*


I personally would love if he had lived, but it wouldn't have been as exciting; and I was always SO happy whenever he came back to the past from the future, because it reminded me he was alive. <3
over a year ago sevendeadlysins said…
Oh my god ALIVE! At least for season 7. It upset me, too, because there was that one episode in season 7 that he was in, and I about had a seizure, then the stupid Avatars ruin his appearance. That just made me wish he could have been there in person, even though little Chris was.

Would you rather Phoebe have stayed with Cole until the end, or the way it was with Coop?
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
heart
**LOL, same, sevendeadlysins! I hated how the stupid Avatars ruined his appearances!

I liked it the way it was! =)

Would you rather that Leo had not become an Elder, or the way it was with him becoming one?
over a year ago sevendeadlysins said…
Hmm... way it was? I am actually watching S6 right now, trying to answer that question myself. I mean, the future wouldn't have been changed if he hadn't, so I guess yeah, way it was.

Would you rather Phoebe had died instead of Prue?
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
cool
**LOL, ya, but wouldn't Piper and Leo not have divorced?

No. I would have been just so uber upset if Phoebe had died-more than Prue's.


Would you rather Billie had never been on the show or the way it was?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
i liked billie she brought something new to the show

would you rather prue was summoned a few times after her death (like they do with grams) or the way it was
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
The way it was,actually.

Would you rather have Jason to give Phoebe another chance after finding she was a witch or the way it was?
over a year ago sevendeadlysins said…
Um... I think the way it was. I mean, I liked Jason at the beginning but I started to dislike him, so it did finish off the relationship, which was fine with me.

Would you rather Billie had died at the end of Season 8 or the way it was?
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
The way it was. I liked Billie

Would you rather one of the sisters to kill Christie or the way it was?
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
the way it was

would you rather have seen Melinda come back from the future like Wyatt and Chris did or the way it was?
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
big smile
I would have liked to seen Melinda. It was weird seeing her and then just not...I would've loved to see Wyatt and Chris have a little sister! ♥

Would you rather Chris be the more powerful one or the way it was?

I honestly don't get it. Chris was conceived when Leo was an Elder, and he has more powers, so how was WYATT the more powerful one?

over a year ago sevendeadlysins said…
Hmm, I am torn. Probably the way it was. After all, if Chris had been the more powerful one, he probably would have been the evil one, if all went similarly, because Wyatt had more control with more powers. And I just like Chris too much to see him evil.

Would you rather the Charmed Ones not fake their own deaths at the end of S7- and with the transformations- or the way it was?
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
the way it was

would you rather have Chris to get his heeling power or the way it was?

Oh,and Janie,I don't get it,too.I keep saying that too myself,Chris is part elder,part witch,he should've had more powers.I guess the writers didn't really think it all the way through.
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
big smile
^Thanks, Ellen. It's been bugging me for ages, LOL. XD

I'd love for him to have his healing power.

Would you rather Leo stay a whitelighter or the way it was?
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
you're welcome,Janie:)

the way it was.

Would you rather have Kyle to stay alive as a human being or the way it was?
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
big smile
The way it was.

Would you rather Prue have met Paige at least once or the way it was?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
i think it would have been cool of they had met

Ellen and Janie I'm pretty sure Chris should have been the more powerful brother except for the fact they Wyatt is the twice blessed child which makes him more powerful than and elder and a witch's child

would you rather cole stayed as belthazor or the way it was
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
big smile
Oh, hard...I guess the way it was. I liked him and Phoebe together. =)

Would you rather Christy had never been on the show, or the way it was?
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
The way it was,she was cool,in a dangerous way


Would you rather have the creators made a spin-off or the way it is/was?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
a spin off with Chris and Wyatt would be amazing

would you rather Paige appeared a couple of times in the first 3 seasons or the way it was
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
the way it was

would you rather have old Phoebe(the three faces of phoebe)to live or the way it was?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
the way it was

would you rather phoebe be older and piper be the young delinquent (seasons 1-3) or the way it was
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
the way it was,they were perfect

would you rather have leo not to become an avatar or the way it was?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
the way it was

would you rather Paige marry Glenn or the way it was
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
the way it was

would you rather have prue stayed and phoebe died or the way it was?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
the way it was i love phoebe

would you rather andy stuck around for longer or the way it was
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
the way it was

would you rather have Chris to have a few more come back episodes or the way it was?
over a year ago mimialliwell said…
chis can come back i like him

would you rather piper dated around more or the way it was
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
the way it was,she belonged with Leo

would you rather have Kira to become human and live or the way it was?
over a year ago friendsfan101 said…
mischievous
Become a human and live...*now I remember who she is! LOL you'll understand this when you see my comment for the least favorite character...*


Would you rather Cole have been alive as an Avatar or the way it was?
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
the way it was,I hate the Avatars

would you rather have Piper have the power of premonitions and Phoebe the power of freezing or the way it was?
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!