Would've been awesome if 2 and 3 were like the fourth movie

A C, only because I thought Princess was the one thing that made the film watchable.

@ SentinelPrime89 Good point. At least Legend of the Saw-Toothed Cave has shown that the series is going in the right direction.

I'm just upset that it took this long and only because another animation company jumped in to get Crest off their asses.

I think the fourth film improved a lot character and plot wise

I hate it when people forget that films with high budgets (I'm looking you FF) have bad graphics. Crest doesn't get a lot of funding.

it's a A- for me

I thought it was ok. it had some weird cloud thing in one scene.

I'd give 1, 2, and 4 all good ratings.
A&O1: 9 / 10
A&O2: 9 / 10
A&O3: ??? / 10 (I've only seen it once back when it was released so I can't really rate it)
A&O4: 10 / 10